Sunday, November 19, 2017

Rumble in the (Retail) Jungle!

As holiday shopping season is upon us, millions of people would be shopping for gifts for their loved ones and for themselves. One week from now, Americans would have finished their Thanksgiving dinners and shopped till drop during "Black Friday" followed by "Cyber Monday" and "Terrific Tuesday" and "Wonderful Wednesdays" and so on. Retailers can be quite creative in coining the terms as we had seen with "Singles Day (11/11)" in China and "Prime Day (7/11) by Amazon". Thanks to Expanding Amazon Jungle, retail landscape is changing dramatically. In last 12 months, Amazon stock is up by 50% while combined market cap of key retailers (Target, Macy's and others) have gone down by 40%. Market is sending clear signals who is winning retail wars. And then there is Walmart. Last week Walmart published it's quarterly results and surprised everyone with kind of progress it had made. So what does it has to do with "Rumble in The Jungle"?
For sports fan and history buffs, one would know about historic boxing fight between World Heavyweight Champion George Foreman and challenger Mohammad Ali in Zaire, Africa in 1974. This fight was promoted as "Rumble in the Jungle" and many consider it as greatest sporting event of the century (Indians would not agree since for Indians India's 1983 Cricket World Cup win against West Indies is still the greatest sporting event of all time). Ali won the boxing fight by knockout in 8th round.
Rumble in the Jungle is good analogy to look at emerging retail fight between Walmart vs Amazon (I did consider David vs Goliath but it does not fit since both companies are so big). Let's look at key attributes of both companies:
Amazon: 
  • Sales: Over $150 Billion growing at double digit
  • Profits: Does not matter since its in investment phase for last 20 years (EBITDA: $12 Billion)
  • Market Cap: Over $550 Billion
  • Key strategy pillars:
    • Leader in online shopping
    • Prime membership
    • Entry in in-store/grocery with Whole Foods 
    • AWS - crown jewel
    • Relentless focus on customer
Walmart:
  • Sales: Close to $500 Billion growing at 1%
  • Profits: $13 Billion (EBITDA: $32 Billion)
  • Market Cap: Close to $300 Billion
  • Key strategy pillars:
    • Leader in in-store/grocery shopping
    • Excellent presence with stores in three formats (Neighborhood market, Superstore and Sam's Club)
    • Everyday low-prices
    • Good momentum in online presence with Jet.com
As you can see, both companies have key strengths which have started producing results and getting rewarded. Both are preparing for fight which would go on for a decade (boxing fight went for 8 rounds). Unlike the boxing fight, there would not be knockout in this fight. So looking all the way into 2030, both of these companies would be winners. However in the rumble, other companies (watch out Target, Macy's, Kohl's and so on) may get trampled. What does it mean to making investment decision? If "retail" is the sector you get excited about, I would recommend picking one of both of these companies for investment and stay away from other retailers (Home Depot and Costco may be exception to this).
Have a great Thanksgiving!


Sunday, November 12, 2017

Vision without Execution is Hallucination!

The quote "Vision without Execution is Hallucination" has been attributed to Thomas Edison and Henry Ford. Both of these men were great visionary and made profound difference in human-kind by executing on those visions. Why is this quote so important in today's world? As earnings season is wrapping up, we see incidence of "execution" or "hallucinations" in almost every earnings report. The companies which have great vision and great execution (Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Google, Facebook, Intel, Nvidia, Netflix and many others) did extremely well and got rewarded with stock price gains. Apple being best of them would become first trillion $ market cap company in few weeks. Steve Jobs was great visionary but what made today's Apple is Tim Cook's almost flawless and laser-sharp execution! Tim Cook had added more than $500 Billion into Apple's market cap in less than 6 years. That's double of what Steve Jobs added during nearly two decades at Apple. Same story with Satya Nadella. Great vision and execution around cloud and software-as-servicve! I particularly admire Netflix CEO Reed Hastings' vision and execution. Moving to streaming world by killing its own cash-cow of shipping DVD was a gutsy vision and almost bankrupted Netflix. Another similar gutsy vision of creating original content (even at expense of spoiling relationships with big media companies like Disney) and executing on both of these visions with persistence has turned Netflix into an unstoppable force in entertainment. This is forcing companies like Disney to rethink its vision and execution for the new world of entertainment. Who would have thought?
Now let's look at other side -  companies which have great vision but are faltering in their execution.

  • Tesla: I admire Elon Musk and his visions in so many fields. Elon is Steve Jobs of 21st century and like Apple for Steve Jobs, Tesla is for Elon Musk. Unfortunately recent reports on struggles on Model 3 production is creating doubts regarding execution capabilities (I am not happy that delivery of my model 3 is pushed out by few months). Execution on production ramp-up an delivery of model 3 to nearly half-million customers who have paid advance of $1000 would decide fate of Tesla. So Elon, it's time to execute on your great vision! (as a side note, Steve Jobs and Apple had similar phase when Steve's execution on his pet project "Lisa" computer faltered)
  • Snap: Evan Spiegel found a great niche of "vanishing messages" and has evolved Snap's vision to be a camera company helping people the way they live and communicate. However since Snap went public, it has failed in its execution every quarter. Kids love the app because of its stories and creative tools (my knowledge of snap app is limited as you would have guessed). But lack of focus (trying to change from social network to camera company) and poor execution (inventory write-down of $40M on Spectacles) is creating a narrative that Snap would go same way as Twitter and GoPro (and would never be able to match Facebook's vision and execution)
  • General Electric: And finally company which was formed by merging Thomas Edison's companies is faltering in its execution for almost 10 years. Today's GE lacks both vision and execution for 21st century. Its stock is at multi-year low and could be removed from DOW index first time (GE is the only company which had stayed in DOW since index was created). Everyone is awaiting for new CEO John Flannery to define a new GE for 21st century creating new vision and execute on it. I am confident that company which had survived two world-wars, great depression, great recession and many ups-and-down would be able to survive and thrive!
Energy markets are back on upswing as I predicted back in July. Given aggressive stance of Saudi Arabia and synchronized global GDP growth oil price would cross $60. Energy stocks would finally turn around in 2018 after nearly 3 years of under-performance.
It's one year anniversary since biggest surprise in political history of USA. More on that next week!

Sunday, November 05, 2017

GOP Tax Act: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly!

Finally long-awaited GOP and Trump Tax Act was published last week after last minute delay of 24 hours. What started as "biggest tax reforms this country had seen ever" campaign promise turned out to be just another GOP "give-away" to its benefactors! This is what happens when you try to govern one-sided which limits tax cuts to fit within $1.5 trillion deficit increase over decade. If only discussions included all sides the way President Reagan did with 1986 Tax Reforms, we would have seen much different proposal. I am sure you must have read many articles to try to understand your personal tax situation. So I am not going to repeat them here. You can refer to Tax Act details in article by Tax foundation.  Being a movie buff, I wanted to look at Tax Act in light of one of all time favorite movie "The Good, the Bad and the Ugly". Similar to the movie plot, the actors of this Tax Act are trying to find "fortune" in buried cache of over $20 Trillion deficit amid the chaos of DC politics! While we know who is Good (American People), the Bad and the Ugly (any guesses for who is bad and who is ugly?), let's look at some of the specifics of tax act proposals

The Good:

  • Simplifying 7 tax brackets to 4
  • Removal of AMT
  • Doubling of standard deduction
  • Increase in child tax credit to $1600
  • Territorial taxes for companies and repatriation of overseas holdings (companies would bring back trillions to USA)
The Bad:
  • Corporate tax rate cut to 20% (from 35%). While this was also good thing, such significant change would only increase company profits which are already at all time high as reflected by stock market rise. In trickle down economics, companies should pass these to workers. But that almost never happen. Reduction of corporate rates to 25-28% while balancing out reduction in individual taxes would have been "good" thing
  • Increase in lowest tax bracket from 10% to 12%. While some of this would offset due to increased deduction, the actual savings to lowest bracket is much lower than highest brackets
  • Elimination of estate tax after 6 years. This was definitely a give-away to GOP "friends and families". While gradual increase in total estate taxes makes sense, eliminating this completely would force future generations of "rich" families not work at all (this is what happens in countries like India and many other Asian and European countries).
The Ugly:
  • Cap on deduction for property ($10K) and elimination of deduction for local and state taxes. This was directly aimed at "Blue" states like California and New York and very partisan. Citizens of these states already pay very high tax rates and capping these deductions would make it worse
  • Limits on mortgage deduction to $500K of mortgage. Try buying a house in coastal states!
  • Pass thru rate for businesses - this opens up so many loopholes (unlike what was promised) that tax consultants would have a field day
  • Elimination of student loan interest deduction. This was one of the smallest savings but GOP never cared about higher education so I am not surprised that they took it out
In summary tax act proposal falls short of grand vision President Trump had during campaign. Even in size, this is one of the smallest (0.9% of GDP) in last 100 years. I am sure hectic lobbying and debates and alternate proposals must be flying in DC and final bill would change.
As in the movie, finally the Good (The People) would decide what happens to the Bad and the Ugly in 2018 and 2020 elections!




Diyas, Democrats & Data Centers...!

Happy Diwali and Naya Saal Mubarak! What a week to light the diyas: a blue wave, the first national referendum on AI data centers, the worst...